Skip to content

Review consensus

MSI Claw 8 AI+ A2VM: what the reviews agree on

By ElvisPublished

Reviewers agree the Lunar Lake Claw 8 AI+ fixes what sank the first Claw: it is faster than the ROG Ally X by roughly 10 to 30 percent depending on the test, with battery life that is long in most tests and a large 8-inch 1200p IPS screen. Complaints are consistent too: $899 to $900 at launch is a lot, Windows and MSI Center M still feel rough, and an OLED option is missed.

We haven't tested the Claw 8 AI+ ourselves. This page pulls together what published reviews and video tests found, with each outlet linked where it's mentioned.

Our take

The Lunar Lake Claw does what its predecessor could not: it beats the ROG Ally X on frame rates in most of the tests reviewers ran, it matches the Ally X's runtime in PC Gamer's gaming test though Tom's Guide's web test put the Ally X ahead while Notebookcheck's ran almost 24 hours, and the 8-inch screen earns its size. Where it falls short is the finish. Reviewers keep returning to a basic MSI Center M, a Quick Settings overlay that stalls, a divisive D-pad and a body that is heavy for its class.

The launch price is the real argument. Reviewers split between 'worth $100 over the Ally X' and 'a touch too expensive', and that is a fair reading of a handheld whose lead is 10 to 30 percent rather than a different tier. Pick it if the larger screen and the extra speed are what you want, and expect to tinker with power profiles. For the current price, check the device page.

Elvis

Good fit if

  • Players who want a big 1200p 120 Hz screen and faster frame rates than the ROG Ally X, and accept paying more at launch pricing
  • Anyone who also uses the handheld as a docked or desktop-replacement Windows PC, since both Thunderbolt 4 ports are called out as useful
  • Long sessions where Hall effect sticks and triggers and a large chassis matter more than pocketability

Look elsewhere if

  • You want a compact, light handheld, since reviewers call it chunky and Tom's Guide says smaller hands may find it unwieldy
  • You want OLED contrast, which this IPS model does not have
  • You want the most refined build and software, since PC Gamer finds the ROG Ally X's buttons more premium and Notebookcheck says Armoury Crate offers more functions

Performance

Reviews that compared it with the ROG Ally X found the Claw ahead or level, by about 10 up to 30 percent where it led. Reviews disagree on how it stands against newer AMD chips, and modern heavy games still need upscaling.

  • Engadget saw frame rates 10 to 15 percent above the ROG Ally X. In Cyberpunk 2077 at 800p, medium settings and a 30 W preset it got 75 fps against 65 fps. Engadget notes MSI's mid preset runs at 17 W where most rivals use 15 W.
  • Tom's Guide measured Assassin's Creed Mirage at 1080p at 30 fps against 23 fps on the Ally X, and DiRT 5 at 720p at 37.9 against 30.5 fps. Notebookcheck put its standard game tests about 10 percent above the Ally X and 25 percent above the first Claw.
  • PC Gamer found the Claw level with the Ally X in Black Myth: Wukong at medium without upscaling and ahead in F1 24 and Metro Exodus Enhanced. It also saw odd Horizon Zero Dawn behaviour with FSR enabled and suspects drivers.
  • Against AMD's newer chips the picture varies. PC Gamer had the Claw within a few frames of the Ryzen AI HX 370 OneXFly F1 Pro in some games, while GamesRadar+ found the Ryzen 7 8840U Zotac Zone a bit ahead at 1080p. Notebookcheck says only the far pricier GPD Pocket beat it in its standard tests.
  • Demanding recent games still struggle. GamesRadar+ got about 30 fps with dips in DOOM: The Dark Ages using XeSS performance. Club386 measured the same game below 30 fps natively on both Claw and Steam Deck OLED, and Tom's Guide saw Dragon's Dogma 2 at 25 to 28 fps at 1080p low.
  • Club386 measured Cyberpunk 2077 on the Steam Deck preset at 800p without FSR: 49 fps average at 17 W against 33 fps for Steam Deck OLED at 15 W. Moving to 30 W added 24 percent at 800p and 19 percent at 1200p. GTA V kept crashing at startup in Notebookcheck's tests.

Battery life

Most reviews call the 80 Wh battery a strength, but measured runtimes depend heavily on power mode and test. Heavy games last about two to three and a half hours at 17 W. Web tests disagree: Notebookcheck's lasted almost 24 hours, while Tom's Guide's found the Ally X ahead.

  • Notebookcheck ran Cyberpunk 2077 at 150 nits: 1:45 in its fastest mode (about 25 fps) and just under 3.5 hours in AI Engine mode (about 19 fps). Its web test at 150 nits lasted almost 24 hours, and at full brightness over 16.5 hours, at 60 Hz.
  • PC Gamer's PCMark 10 gaming battery test ran 129 minutes, one minute more than the ROG Ally X and nearly double the OneXFly F1 Pro. PC Gamer also played about an hour and a half of Doom (2016) on Ultra on a commute with charge left.
  • Club386 played Cyberpunk 2077 at 50 percent brightness for just under three hours at 17 W and 1 hour 40 minutes at 30 W. At 8 W, light games drained about 20 percent per hour. Engadget got just over three hours in Elden Ring on medium.
  • GamesRadar+ saw over two hours under load in DOOM: The Dark Ages. Tom's Guide's continuous web test at 150 nits lasted 2:22 against 3:04 for the Ally X despite the same 80 Wh capacity, though it puts the 8 W Endurance mode at 12 to 13 hours or more for basic tasks.

Display

The 8-inch 1920x1200 IPS panel at 120 Hz with VRR is described as vibrant and sharp. Reviewers wish for OLED contrast, and Notebookcheck found a cool factory colour balance.

  • Notebookcheck measured 524 cd/m2 at the centre and a contrast ratio above 1,500:1. It noticed a blue cast from the factory calibration, and says the reflective screen struggles in direct sun. It found no PWM flicker, and response times slower than the first Claw.
  • Tom's Guide gives about 475 nits, more than 100 nits below the 597 nits it recorded on Steam Deck OLED, and says that matters little unless you play in direct sun. Engadget gives the brightness as up to 500 nits and sees little to complain about.
  • Club386 misses OLED black levels and a lower brightness floor, and Tom's Guide says OLED would have sweetened the price. Club386 still prefers the extra inch of screen over its Steam Deck for games like The Witcher 3 and Balatro.
  • PC Gamer calls the 8-inch IPS panel noticeably vibrant from first boot, and GamesRadar+ likes the larger 1200p screen as a reason to choose it over the Ally X.

Comfort & controls

Reviewers split

Most reviewers find the grips and Hall effect sticks and triggers good, and Notebookcheck praises the build. They disagree about the D-pad, and several wish for a lighter body or deeper grips.

  • Notebookcheck praises the stable, creak-free case, and says the Hall effect triggers offer slightly more resistance than the Ally X's, which it likes better in play. PC Gamer says the sticks feel great but the Ally X's triggers, bumpers and face buttons feel more premium.
  • The D-pad divides reviewers. GamesRadar+ rates the D-pad poorly because it barely tilts and its cross is curved, and says the A and B buttons sit near the edge of the body. Club386 says it emulates the Xbox Series controller, and Notebookcheck calls it precise and quiet.
  • Tom's Guide gives the weight as 1.75 pounds and finds it tiring in long sessions. It wishes for deeper grips and trigger locks, and says smaller hands may find it too big. Engadget also wants slightly larger grips, and lists only one pair of paddles and no touchpad.
  • PC Gamer lists comfortable ergonomics among its pros, but says the Claw's size makes packing it less automatic than the smaller Ally X. Club386 finds it comfortable for hours and wishes a carry case came in the box.

Heat & noise

Surface temperatures are low in the reviews that measured them. Noise depends on power mode: PC Gamer found it quiet, while Notebookcheck and Club386 heard fans at 30 W.

  • Notebookcheck measured surface maximums of 36.6 C on the top and 34.8 C on the bottom in its stress test, and says the handles barely warm up. PC Gamer reported a maximum CPU temperature of 86 C.
  • Notebookcheck measured 37.3 to 41.4 dB(A) in manual 30 W mode, and 33.4 to 37.3 dB(A) in AI Engine mode, with the fan speed fluctuating even though TDP stayed constant. It would like MSI to fix that behaviour.
  • PC Gamer found the Claw much quieter than the ROG Ally X at 30 W, which it called fairly loud under load. Club386 says the fans become audible at 30 W and fade into the background at 17 W.

Software

MSI Center M is described as basic but functional. Reviewers criticise the power profiles, report Quick Settings problems, and fault Windows 11 on a small screen, while Tom's Guide likes the refreshed app.

  • Notebookcheck says MSI Center M works well overall but lags at times and has fewer features than Armoury Crate on the Ally X. Its AI Engine profile stayed at 17 W in testing, and the 8, 17 and 30 W manual limits are only in the app, not the quick menu.
  • PC Gamer calls MSI's software basic and advises turning AI Engine off and setting power manually, since it disrupted some plugged-in benchmark runs. Engadget calls Center M a bit basic, with all the important functions present.
  • Tom's Guide likes the refreshed Center M and the semi-transparent Quick Bar with Xbox friends and achievements. Club386 found Quick Settings often became unresponsive or its tabs overlapped, though it saw several updates ship during testing.
  • Reviewers still fault Windows 11 on a handheld. Tom's Guide cites small touch targets and no proper quick resume. GamesRadar+ notes the quick settings use the Xbox overlay instead of a tailored menu, and Engadget calls Windows clunkier than SteamOS.

Value

Reviewers split

At launch pricing of $899 to $900 reviewers called it among the priciest handhelds, but they split on whether the performance justifies it.

  • Notebookcheck says the $899.99 price is justified by performance and features, though it is no bargain. PC Gamer judges $900 fair for what it delivers, yet leans toward the $800 Ally X overall for portability and refinement.
  • Engadget says the $800 Ally X remains the better value and that the Legion Go offers similar power for less. Club386 calls it the most expensive handheld from the major makers and says a $100 discount would make it fairly priced.
  • Tom's Guide says $899 edges into gaming laptop territory, and still names it its favourite pick, worth the extra $100 over the Ally X in its view. GamesRadar+ lists the price among its cons and compares it with the coming Nintendo Switch 2.